In light of all the conversations about free speech and firings in the news, I want to step back and look at this from an HR perspective. As someone who has managed people, written policies, and had to make hard calls, I can tell you one thing with certainty: the people who work for you carry your company’s culture and voice.

If they don’t align with that culture or voice, you can terminate them. But here’s the key: you need to protect yourself and your business in how you do it.

Free Speech vs. Employment Consequences

The First Amendment is one of the most quoted parts of our Constitution, but it’s often misunderstood. Here’s the truth:

• The First Amendment protects you from the government limiting your speech.
  
  

• It does not protect you from the consequences of speech in private life.
  
  

• Employers, businesses, and even news agencies can (and do) set their own standards.
  
  

That means if an employee says something publicly that goes against your values, damages your reputation, or alienates your customers, you as the employer have the right to act.

Why Written Policies Matter

This is where so many business owners get tripped up. If you don’t have clear, written standards — like a code of conduct and social media guidelines in your employee manual — you’re vulnerable.

Because while you can fire someone, some speech is legally protected:

• Speech tied to discrimination laws
  
  

• Union organizing and workplace conditions
  
  

• Whistleblowing or reporting violations
  
  

Without documented policies, a firing that felt justified could be challenged in court and look like discrimination. That’s a risk no business owner wants to take.

Best practice: Always have clear, written policies. Always apply them consistently. And always consult an employment lawyer when in doubt.

The Beauty of Capitalism and Free Enterprise

This is also part of the bigger picture of what makes our society unique. We live in a capitalist, free-enterprise system. That means the government doesn’t dictate who you hire or fire. You own your business, and you get to shape the culture and voice of your company.

When people say “what about free speech?” — let’s be clear. Free speech means the government can’t silence you. But your employer can hold you accountable if your words clash with their culture. And that’s not a bad thing. That’s the beauty of capitalism: the freedom to build something that reflects your values, with the people you choose to represent it.

Final Word

At the end of the day, your business is only as strong as the culture you protect. Free speech is a right, but accountability in the workplace is a responsibility. Protect your business with clear policies, protect your culture by hiring people who align with it, and protect yourself by seeking legal guidance when needed.

That’s how you honor both freedom and responsibility in a truly free-enterprise society.

🌟Ready to safeguard your business culture and avoid costly mistakes?

Book a call with me today, and together we’ll make sure your business is protected and your culture stays strong.
Book your free 20-minute clarity call

Subscribe for weekly encouragement straight to your inbox!